The Comics Curmudgeon is funnier in an immediate way; Funny Pages was funnier in a more aggregate way. They tended to build up their jokes better, as they had a week's worth of material to work with.
But I also read FP for a couple of years, and I've read CC for a couple of weeks. I may prove myself wrong.
I see your point Bill.
I think what I most remember from that is the judgement of For Better Or Worse... "For Worse!" "For Better!"